Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Reed Griggs's avatar

I appreciate the passion in your writing about listening. But as for the title, fog is analog.

As a saxophonist, the link I think about between Coltrane and Brecker is practice. Lots and lots of practice.

And the difference in the link is what they practiced. Coltrane included musics of many cultures in his practice, compositions, and performances - spirituals, ragas, scales from Africa, Middle East, Asia, Europe, Eastern Europe, South America, etc. but I haven't seen that same wide scope in what I know of musical Brecker's disciplined diet.

Coltrane was on a path to transcend his lived experience through becoming a disciple of Ravi Shankar. Brecker's path did not cross into becoming a student of another master.

Perhaps I am ill informed. I am hungry to learn.

Expand full comment
Barbara Anel's avatar

Oh, Bret! I read your words and heard my sister Lili-"when I sing, I want to sound like a saxophone." Her muse id Michael Brecker. I saw him every time he played in NY, particularly in his and Randy's club, "7th Avenue South." It was school for me, with Don Grolnick as his pianist (I play the piano) and the rest was church. On top of it all, he was the nicest person. I am certain Lili will write a post. Thank you, Bret. This article took me "there."

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?