Syncopated Justice
Syncopated Justice
HomeNotesSojournsJazz VideoTechExpat A Go GoFictionNotesArchiveAbout
Sign in
Sojourns

Jewish Humor: A Legacy of Resilience…

Bret Primack
Feb 10, 2025

From the Catskills to TikTok

Read →
19 Comments
User's avatar
WTK's avatar
WTK
Feb 10, 2025

One can easily argue that American humor IS Jewish humor.

Just as American music IS Black music.

May both remain invincible.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Ken Chernoff's avatar
Ken Chernoff
Feb 11, 2025

Very clever .... and hilarious, boychick!

Like (1)
Reply
Share
Chuck Koton's avatar
Chuck Koton
Feb 11, 2025

id say much of the above can equally apply to African Americans...outsiders in racist American society, for Jews there was the Borscht Belt and the Chitlin Circuit where Black comedians honed their humor...

Like (1)
Reply
Share
Kevin McTernan's avatar
Kevin McTernan
Feb 10, 2025

I loved this!

Laughter is the WD40 of the daily grind.

Like (2)
Reply (1)
Share
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Feb 10, 2025

well said....thanks

Like
Reply
Share
George M's avatar
George M
Feb 10, 2025

I had the great luck to have been in high school when Mad Comics broke into my little world, in Brooklyn, NY. I devoured every issue with glee, feeding on the bizarre graphic and verbal highjinks.

*Seinfeld* is still, for me, top notch in reruns. I think many apparently "non-Jewish" TV shows like *Frasier* and *M*A*S*H* have the elements of absurdism, satire, frustration and neurosis which I and countless others love. We're blessed with the great sense of humor that Jewish comic geniuses have given this and all other people who love to laugh at life's curveballs (and far worse).

Like (1)
Reply (1)
Share
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Feb 10, 2025

Sonny Rollins, who has a great sense of humor, has always been a huge fan of Mad Magazine, so you're in good company, George.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Todd Coolman's avatar
Todd Coolman
Feb 10, 2025

I often wondered why the era of the Catskills Showrooms was so dominated by comedians who happened to be Jewish. Nearly all of them who eventually migrated to television were also Jewish. I heard a plausible theory about the origins of Jewish humor that pointed to the Holocaust era. Given that the Jews were stripped of all humanity and deprived of any tools to fight back at their oppressors, they found self-deprecating humor to be such a tool. They discovered that they could make better fun of themselves through humor than the Germans could, thus giving them a leg up on their captors...perhaps the only one available. Any thoughts on this theory?

Like (1)
Reply (2)
Share
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Feb 10, 2025

I think you nailed it.

Like
Reply
Share
Chuck Koton's avatar
Chuck Koton
Feb 11, 2025

Id say it goes back earlier than the Holocaust since except for the nazis meticulous industrialization of Jewish murder, the East European/Russian anti-Semitic mistreatment already had generated a culture of Jewish humor as survival...

Like
Reply
Share
Michael Schuster's avatar
Michael Schuster
Feb 10, 2025

Veteran of the Catskills scene circa 1970s here. Great column. For a current take on Jewish humor check out a guy named Modi. He's currently on tour and we'll be seeing him in Hartford next month. Need to laugh now more than ever!

Like (1)
Reply (1)
Share
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Feb 10, 2025

Modi's funny. I've seen some of his videos.

Like
Reply
Share
Su Terry's avatar
Su Terry
Feb 11, 2025

Mad Magazine's "Rewriting Your Way To a PhD " has always been my guiding light.

Like
Reply
Share
Su Terry's avatar
Su Terry
Feb 10, 2025

Once I was touring in Florida with Leslie Uggams. The comic who opened for us had this joke: "What is it with all the buffalo wing joints here? Buffalo wings, buffalo wings, everywhere you turn. Geez, when I was a kid, the sky was black with buffalo. Those poor animals have to walk now!"

He tried it for 3 shows, but the only laughter came from the band, backstage. He had to cut the joke.

Like
Reply (1)
Share
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Feb 10, 2025

Wonder where that comic is today. Probably working in a Starbucks.

Like
Reply (1)
Share
Su Terry's avatar
Su Terry
Feb 11, 2025

You would definitely need a good sense of humor to work in a Starbucks.

Like
Reply (1)
Share
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Feb 13, 2025

Not for much longer. Starbucks soon will be strictly robots.

Like
Reply (1)
Share
Su Terry's avatar
Su Terry
Feb 13, 2025

I'm sure you're right.

Like
Reply
Share
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 10, 2025
Comment deleted
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Feb 13, 2025

If not for humor, how will we survive this.

Like
Reply
Share
Syncopated Justice

Dispatches from the edge of the empire, one beat at a time.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Arcadian Arts · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.