Syncopated Justice
Syncopated Justice
HomeNotesSojournsJazz VideoTechExpat A Go GoFictionNotesArchiveAbout
Sign in
Tech

Does Human Creativity Still Matter When AI…

Bret Primack
Jan 5

There will never be an AI Coltrane

Read →
7 Comments
User's avatar
Jesus Millan Jr's avatar
Jesus Millan Jr
Jan 5

Great Article Bret!!! I would say this, you can't quantize Rhythm and Syncopation that comes natural in Jazz and really in Latin Music as well. I was Listening to a Christian Salsa Tune Last Year with My Cousin, and I Honestly could tell it was totally AI by the Compression of the Sound of the Vocals and The Conga Drums were totally Robotic. AI is Good For Somethings, but for Music? I Honestly Don't know about that except for Isolation Tracks AI Is Good, but for Songwriting? Not for me. Great Article Bret You Create An AI Coltrane, but it can't Replace the Real Trane

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Bevan Manson's avatar
Bevan Manson
Jan 5

The music that I have heard from AI is simply inept in obvious and jumbled ways. Jumbled, as it sounds like arbitrary choices are made often regarding harmony, melodic ideas, stylistic consistency (or lack thereof). Most obvious is a robotic quality that in the end sounds bland and flat. Aside from its lack of humanity, it can't ever rival a Coltrane, Beethoven, or Mahler simply due to its aural incompetence.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Justin E. Schutz's avatar
Justin E. Schutz
Jan 5

WORD. truth and soul. humanity.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
michael j stevens's avatar
michael j stevens
Jan 6

Bret. This was a great article. Extremely thoughtful and articulate. Thanks!!!

Like (1)
Reply
Share
Kep Taiz's avatar
Kep Taiz
Jan 13

Wonderful and heartwarming Bret!Neede that

Like
Reply
Share
Manuela Thiess Garcia's avatar
Manuela Thiess Garcia
Jan 8

What strikes me most about your observations here, is the notion that AI carries with it no vulnerability, the vulnerability of taking creative chances, which adds the deep personalization to our work. What we dare, and what we dare not.

I refuse to use AI unless google forces it when I do a search, and then I check the google sources. It is a matter of principle, though it matters little to anyone else, and though in another couple of years the world will be totally reliant on it and programmed by it (I feel certain politically, as well, as Musk has already demonstrated), my little stand on the matter makes me like myself better.

Like
Reply
Share
Barbara Anel's avatar
Barbara Anel
Jan 5

The last two paragraphs of this article should be posted and scrolled on loop in every city's major transportation hub-airports, train stations, highway overpasses.

Thank you, Bret. You have so eloquently verbalized my sentiments about AI.

Like
Reply
Share
Syncopated Justice

Dispatches from the edge of the empire, one beat at a time.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Arcadian Arts · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.