Syncopated Justice
Syncopated Justice
HomeNotesSojournsJazz VideoTechExpat A Go GoFictionNotesArchiveAbout
Sign in
Jazz Video

Hank Mobley - Tenor Middleweight Champion

Bret Primack
Jan 21

A Master of Contrasts

Read →
10 Comments
User's avatar
Peter L Bernhardt's avatar
Peter L Bernhardt
Jan 21

Thanks, Bret, for your writing about my all time favorite tenor player (ever since I in 1961 bought the album Meet You At The Jazz Corner Of The World with the Jazz Messengers). Hank Mobley's qualities as a composer can not be overrated, lots of hard bop and bluesy tunes not often played to day. Listen to Hipsippy Blues and Just Coolin'.

Like (1)
Reply
Share
richard eland's avatar
richard eland
Jan 22

I've read at least 2 separate accounts. One was that Coltrane was in the building on another matter and Miles bumped into him and asked him to sit in. The other one is that Miles invited Coltrane to the session in advance. In any case, Coltrane had already left the group the year before.

Like (1)
Reply
Share
richard eland's avatar
richard eland
Jan 21

Someday My Prince Will Come - studio album, no? Must have been a weird scene with Coltrane showing up as well.

Like (1)
Reply (1)
Share
Chuck Koton's avatar
Chuck Koton
Jan 21

what do you mean by "showing up?"

Like
Reply
Share
Justin E. Schutz's avatar
Justin E. Schutz
Jan 22

This is a great clip, Mobley displays everything you have described about his playing. A player better be sure they know their voice to take on Summertime. I’ve always admired Tootie Heath and he’s definitely doing his thing on this piece. Appreciate being reminded of Mobley. Another great post.

Like
Reply
Share
Chuck Koton's avatar
Chuck Koton
Jan 21

Sweet tribute to Mr Mobley!!! so who's the middleweight alto champ?

Like
Reply (2)
Share
Bret Primack's avatar
Bret Primack
Jan 21

If we're talking historically, Charlie Parker is the undisputed heavyweight, not middleweight. He revolutionized the instrument and the music itself.

But for the "middleweight" tier - the brilliant players who aren't quite Bird but are absolute masters - you might be thinking of someone such as:

Cannonball Adderley - Soulful, bluesy, incredibly swinging. He had that big, warm sound and could play his heart out without the angular complexity of Bird.

Art Pepper - West Coast cool, deeply emotional, a gorgeous lyrical player with his own distinct voice.

Lou Donaldson - Hard bop master, funky and accessible, never trying to be Bird but carving out his own groove-oriented territory.

Phil Woods - Technically brilliant, clearly influenced by Parker but with his own muscular, confident approach.

In the modern era, you might consider Gary Bartz or Kenny Garrett or Vincent Herring in that category - major players who command respect without claiming to be revolutionaries.

But here's the thing: "middleweight" might be unfair to any of these cats. They're all heavyweights in their own right. They just had the misfortune of existing in the same universe as Charlie Parker, who redefined what was possible on the alto.

Like (3)
Reply (2)
Share
Michael Patrick O’Leary's avatar
Michael Patrick O’Leary
Jan 22

I had the privilege of seeing Cannonball Adderley, Gary Bartz and Kenny Garrett live.

Like
Reply
Share
Chuck Koton's avatar
Chuck Koton
Jan 22

well, "middleweight" is just as unfair to Mobley but theres some sense to that...so lets think in terms of those in Bird's orbit...maybe Stitt is the middleweight champ but again, yes, it is to an extent, unfair!

Like
Reply
Share
Andy Geiger's avatar
Andy Geiger
Jan 24

Leonard Feather, the critic, coined the “middleweight champ” reference to Hank. It was not meant as a slight, but of course it turned out to be because it was misunderstood. It referenced tone and volume comparatively, not improvisational or composing skills. Feather could do damage!

I think Mobley is one of the giants of the tenor sax from the post-bop era.

Like
Reply
Share
Syncopated Justice

Dispatches from the edge of the empire, one beat at a time.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Arcadian Arts · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.