Syncopated Justice
Syncopated Justice
HomeNotesSojournsJazz VideoTechExpat A Go GoFictionNotesArchiveAbout
Sign in
Sojourns

The Forgotten Master: How Hank Mobley…

Bret Primack
Jan 23

The hard bop genius who wrote an album in prison, died homeless, and was celebrated only after it was too late

Read →
42 Comments
User's avatar
@suzannecloud's avatar
@suzannecloud
Jan 23

Bret, I remember one of those dates in Philly toward the end (1980s). Hank played a date at a club called The Upstairs on Broad Street. Pianist Sam Dockery played the gig with him. I couldn't get a ticket because the place was packed. So afterward I asked Sam how the gig went, and he told me Hank seemed tired and sat down a lot, but he was still on top of the music. Later, Mobley sat in at a jam session at Natalie's in town. The celebrated author/saxophonist James McBride (who wasn't celebrated at the time since his first book "The Color of Water" hadn't come out yet) was there writing an article on Philly jazz for the Philadelphia Inquirer. McBride totally trashed Mobley in print and when the story came out, the community ran the writer out of town. McBride ended up covering the Michael Jackson tour - the one where Jackson's hair caught on fire.

Like (12)
Reply (1)
Share
skip heller's avatar
skip heller
Jan 27

I was at that Upstairs gig, and Hank sounded very good, like he had just steeped right out of the Soul Station session. So did Sam Dockery, who seemed at the time mostly to have been playing weddings (I was in the band he was in) or solo piano (at the Frog). I was very surprised by what James McBride wrote when that article came out because it didn't resemble what I had just seen.

Like (2)
Reply (1)
Share
@suzannecloud's avatar
@suzannecloud
Jan 28

Wow, Skip, you were at that gig? Wish I could have been there. Thanks for your comment. Bret's story was so very sad.

Like
Reply (1)
Share
skip heller's avatar
skip heller
Jan 28

I'm glad Hank Mobley is getting a second look. The reexamination flatters him. The idea that Sonny and Trane and the apocolyptic tenor approach is the end-all and be-all really does the music an injustice.

Like (2)
Reply (1)
Share
@suzannecloud's avatar
@suzannecloud
Jan 28

Totally agree. It would make a good film about how the music business operates then and now

Like (1)
Reply
Share
Brian M. Bacchus's avatar
Brian M. Bacchus
Jan 24

We should keep in mind that Alfred Lion and Francis Wolff ran a monumental label that documented so much for 30 years of this music. The label was sold in 1965 so really had no stewardship until George Butler in 1971/2 (until 1978/9), who had some success with crossover records from Donald Byrd, Earl Klugh and Bobbi Humphrey.and then Michael Cuscuna entered the picture basically as archiver and a producer in 1975 (the brown paper bag 2-fers and then this classic series and then of course the Capitol and Mosaic years). In that time from 1965 til at least the late 70's, the overall US music landscape had changed so much, especially for jazz, and Blue Note as a label had changed corporate hands a few times; Liberty, United Artists, Capitol, EMI, to eventually Universal. Lions did record more records than he could reasonably put out or market in his time and I'll admit some of the reasons for not releasing a session that were not business related, seemed odd in hindsight, but it was basically a 1-2 man shop for years and in those days, having even a minor hit (Sidewinder or Song For My Father) could put you out of business. In many ways, it's a miracle they survived as long as they did and certainly a miracle that they documented the amount of pivotal artists and musical movements that they did, giving them all brilliant artwork and full liner notes and of course the Rudy Van Gelder sound. Anyway, I say all this to add some context to Hank and several other musicians whose worked languished in the vaults for too long. Hank also had his own demons to battle, but I can understand his anger, There is a great interview with Hank that Billy Banks did when he was on WKCR in the late 70s/early 80's I believe, with The Musician's Show. Someone somewhere I'm sure has it. Hank was off the scene for so long that people were calling in asking Billy when the interview was done and Billy kept having to say, "Hank is still alive, he's right here!" Listeners couldn't believe he was still with us. Hank transitioned in '86.

Like (7)
Reply (2)
Share
Allen Lowe's avatar
Allen Lowe
Feb 17

thanks for saying all that. As I said above, another reason they may not have wanted to release his stuff is that he couldn't support it by touring and playing. Mobley, IMHO, was his own victim. He didn't show up sometimes and he was overall a physical mess.

Like (5)
Reply
Share
Nikolai Grut's avatar
Nikolai Grut
May 29

What do you mean: a minor hit could put you out of business . . .?

Nick/abagthisbig

Like
Reply (1)
Share
Brian M. Bacchus's avatar
Brian M. Bacchus
May 29

If you had a hit where all of a sudden you got way more orders than usual, you'd have to spend more money in producing more vinyl to service. But you usually wouldn't get paid on a timely basis from your distributor so even though all of a sudden you were selling more of just one item at retail, you might not see the returns on it so you could order more to fulfill the request. And sometimes distributors might hold out paying you until you gave them more of your hit. Small labels like Strata-East, that was basically artist run (Stanley Cowell & Charles Tolliver), had that very problem when Gil Scott-Heron's single of The Bottle became a huge radio hit and Winter in America all of a sudden was a hit album. Basically you have a cashflow problem. You overextend yourself fiscally to fill the orders of your hit, but you're not getting paid as fast as items are selling. if it's a minor hit, you might be able to sustain the minor surge, but if its huge, you could end up waiting of folks to pay you after you've laid out too much to sustain the label. Blue note had a few hits over the years, not as big as The Bottle, initially, but Song For My Father, Watermelon Man, and The Sidewinder were when it was just a 2 man operation. Even though they were probably juke box hits and helped fuel some sales on Lee, Herbie and Horace, they probably still weren't able to fully capitalize on it and probably didn't make as many albums to sell as they might have wanted, though I believe they had an interest on the publishing, so had some other revenue coming in as well. Regardless, they weathered through a few while they were still fully independent and a 2 man operation.

Like (1)
Reply (1)
Share
Nikolai Grut's avatar
Nikolai Grut
May 30

Great answer, thank you very much!

Like (1)
Reply
Share
John Fielding Walsh's avatar
John Fielding Walsh
Jan 24

Thanks for posting this. Mobley is my favorite tenor.

Like (3)
Reply
Share
Richard Edelman's avatar
Richard Edelman
Jan 23

Thank you so much for your beautiful telling of this tragic story. Marion Brown introduced me to Hank in Paris in 1968. He struck me then as a real gentleman and a truly genuine human being. Reading about how his life unfolded since then was painful. Needless to say he deserved so much better.

Like (3)
Reply
Share
Robert Fiore's avatar
Robert Fiore
Jan 24

Hank Mobley is one of those players who when playing on someone else’s album have you saying, “Who the hell is that?”

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Andy Geiger's avatar
Andy Geiger
Jan 24

Very sad, and very cruel. I my opinion, Hank was a giant! We have over a dozen albums to celebrate his work, and “Soul Station” is a desert island disc. If you want to play many of his tunes, go to jazzleadsheets.com.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Arthur Rosch's avatar
Arthur Rosch
Jan 23

How utterly painful. I did my homelessness when I was young enough to endure it. It wasn't pleasant. I've listened to Hank Mobley for so long without knowing this story. It should be against the law to impose such sufferings on artists.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Chuck Koton's avatar
Chuck Koton
Jan 23

tragic, tear-inducing read...poignant and important essay, Bret!

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Chrys Roney's avatar
Chrys Roney
Jan 23

Ugh. I was told of a story when Hank tried to see a show at one of the jazz clubs and they ran him off as a homeless person. He managed to get from Philly to NY to see a show. ... One of the musicians recognized him and found him. Just UGH.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Michael Schuster's avatar
Michael Schuster
Jan 23

Thanks Bret for sharing this sad yet not surprising story.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Antonio's avatar
Antonio
Jan 23

Another sad example of what corporate greed brings to the table.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Carl Woideck's avatar
Carl Woideck
Jan 23

THANK YOU, BRET.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
richard eland's avatar
richard eland
Jan 23

Reminds me of Van Gogh.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Alastair Ingram's avatar
Alastair Ingram
Jan 23

One of my favorite tenor players.

Like (2)
Reply
Share
Roger Morgan's avatar
Roger Morgan
Jan 25

I worked in sales at Zapf’s Music Store in the Olney section of North Philly from 1982-1985, which was the largest full-service music store in the region at the time. One Friday evening, a Black gentleman came up to the band instrument counter carrying a well-worn tenor sax case with an instrument needing some TLC. In those days, we used forms in triplicate to write up the repairs. After placing his instrument on the counter and opening the case for me to find the serial number, I passed a pen to him to write his name on the form, on which he wrote: Henry Mobley. I honestly don’t recall him leaving a phone number or an address, or what brand/model tenor he had, but he sure thought of it as a dear friend as he had various small items of memorabilia clipped to the padded underside of the case lid. At that time, I knew of him from his work on a couple of Lee Morgan LPs. I expressed my gratitude for his work after introducing myself. I never saw him again but assume that he picked up his tenor after being repaired, but fondly remember that chance meeting and how he presented himself with grace and humility. It pains me to learn of this tragic reality at the end of Hank’s life.

Like (5)
Reply
Share
John Sheehy's avatar
John Sheehy
Jan 23

I know it’s old news at this point, but i’m continually amazed and stunned at how many jazz musicians just have the most tragic endings juxtaposed with other genres…

Like (1)
Reply
Share
Syncopated Justice

Dispatches from the edge of the empire, one beat at a time.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Arcadian Arts · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.